Hello, friends, and welcome back to Nations 4 Jesus. Today I want to talk about something that happened just last week that should make every believer stop and think. The number one Christian album on iTunes isn't from Chris Tomlin, Forrest Frank, or even Brandon Lake. It's from an AI-generated artist named Solomon Ray. His album Faithful Soul and singles like "Find Your Rest" and "Goodbye Temptation" shot to the top of the charts, and suddenly Christians everywhere are asking a question we never thought we'd have to ask: Can a machine worship God?
This isn't science fiction anymore, friends. This is happening right now. And I believe this is one of the most important conversations the church needs to have as we move deeper into the age of artificial intelligence.
Let me be clear from the start: I'm not anti-technology. I use it every day. I'm recording this podcast with digital equipment. You're probably listening on your phone or computer. And remember, the printing press revolutionized how we spread Scripture. Radio brought sermons into homes. The internet connected believers around the world. Christians have always used tools to advance the gospel.
But there's something fundamentally different about what's happening with AI worship music. And I want us to think through this carefully, Biblically, and with wisdom.
Here's the situation. Christopher Jermaine Townsend—known as Topher in the Christian music world—created an AI-generated artist named Solomon Ray. Using artificial intelligence, he produced worship music that sounds professional, polished, and lyrically Christian. And it's topping the charts. People are streaming it. Churches might even be playing it.
But here's the problem: there's no actual person named Solomon Ray. There's no testimony. No conversion story. No late nights crying out to God. No years of walking with Jesus. Most importantly - No Holy Spirit living inside the "artist." It's code. It's algorithms. It's a machine generating sounds that mimic human worship.
Popular Christian artist Forrest Frank put it bluntly in an Instagram video that went viral. He said, "AI does not have the Holy Spirit inside of it. I personally will not be listening to this." And friends, I think Forrest is onto something crucial here.
Let me ask you a question: What is worship? Is it just nice-sounding music with Christian lyrics? Is it just a melody that makes you feel peaceful? Or is worship something deeper—something that requires a human soul responding to a holy God?
David wrote in Psalm 103, "Bless the Lord, O my soul, and all that is within me, bless His holy name!" Notice what's doing the worshiping—David's soul. His inner being. Everything within him. Worship flows from a redeemed heart that has experienced God's grace, God's mercy, God's presence.
When Paul and Silas sang hymns in prison at midnight in Acts 16, their worship meant something because they were human beings choosing to praise God despite their chains, their wounds, their circumstances. Their worship was an offering of faith in the midst of suffering.
Can an AI do that? Can a machine experience redemption? Can code comprehend the cross? Can an algorithm understand what it means to be forgiven?
The answer is no. And that matters more than we might think.
Now, Topher—the creator of Solomon Ray—argues that AI is simply "a tool for creativity and ministry." He says it enables people with limited resources, training, or ability to share Christ-centered music they could never make on their own. And I understand that argument. There are benefits to AI technology in certain contexts.
Let me be fair and acknowledge some potential positives. AI can help a person with no musical training create something that sounds professional. It can assist churches in creating Scripture-based songs for memorizing verses. It can help independent Christian artists with production and mixing. It can translate songs into multiple languages quickly. These are real benefits.
But here's where we have to be careful. Just because something is useful doesn't mean it's appropriate for worship. Just because technology can do something doesn't mean it should.
Let me give you three reasons why AI-generated worship music is spiritually problematic.
First, worship requires a worshiper. This is the heart of the issue. Worship isn't just about the words or the melody—it's about the posture of the one offering it. Throughout Scripture, worship is always a human heart responding to God. When Moses sang after crossing the Red Sea, when Miriam danced with the tambourine, when Hannah prayed in the temple, when Mary magnified the Lord—these were real people with real faith offering real praise to a real God.
AI has no salvation story. It has never experienced conviction of sin. It has never known the joy of forgiveness. It has never walked through suffering and discovered God's faithfulness. It can simulate emotion, but it cannot experience it. And that's the difference between worship and religious entertainment.
Friends, when we put AI-generated worship on the same level as Spirit-filled music from believers, we're fundamentally misunderstanding what worship is. We're reducing it to a product, a commodity, a sound—instead of recognizing it as a sacred offering from a redeemed soul to a holy God.
Second, this erodes our understanding of the Holy Spirit's role in worship. Ephesians 5:18-19 tells us, "Be filled with the Spirit, speaking to one another in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing and making melody in your heart to the Lord." Did you catch that? We're to be filled with the Spirit when we worship. The Holy Spirit inspires, prompts, and empowers genuine worship.
But AI doesn't have the Holy Spirit. It can't be filled with the Spirit. It can't be led by the Spirit. It's simply following programming, generating output based on data it's been fed. And if we start accepting AI-generated worship as legitimate, we're teaching the next generation that the Holy Spirit's presence in worship is optional—that as long as the lyrics are correct and the melody is pleasing, it doesn't matter if there's any spiritual authenticity behind it.
That's dangerous, friends. That's moving us toward a form of godliness that denies the power thereof—exactly what Paul warned Timothy about in 2 Timothy 3:5.
Third, this could fundamentally change how the church understands worship. Right now, many Christians already struggle to discern the difference between entertainment and worship. We've turned worship leaders into celebrities. We've made worship into a performance. We've let production quality sometimes matter more than spiritual depth.
Now add AI into the mix. If AI-generated songs can top the charts, what happens to faithful Christian musicians who pour their lives into ministry? What happens when churches start choosing music based on cost and convenience rather than spiritual authenticity? What happens when we can customize worship to match our mood, our preferences, our emotions—turning it into a product we consume rather than a sacrifice we offer?
The danger isn't just that AI might create bad theology in lyrics—humans can do that too. The danger is that we start seeing worship as something that can be manufactured, engineered, produced by machines. And once we accept that, we've lost something essential about what it means to worship in spirit and truth.
Jesus said in John 4:23-24, "The hour is coming, and now is, when the true worshipers will worship the Father in spirit and truth; for the Father is seeking such to worship Him. God is Spirit, and those who worship Him must worship in spirit and truth."
Notice that—God is seeking worshipers. Not worship music. Not good production. Not pleasing melodies. Worshipers. People. Human beings whose spirits connect with His Spirit in truth.
So how should we respond to this? Not with fear, but with discernment. AI isn't going away. The technology will only get better. The question is: how will the church navigate this wisely?
Here's what I believe we need to affirm: Humans create worship because humans are redeemed. The Holy Spirit inspires songs through people, not programs. God uses technology, but He indwells believers, not machines.
For personal devotion and church worship, here's a safe principle: AI may assist the creative process, but it should never become the creator of worship itself. Let AI help with production if that's useful. Let technology support the work. But never let it replace Spirit-filled artists whose songs come from real faith, real prayers, real encounters with the living God.
And friends, let's be wise about what we choose to listen to and what we allow in our churches. Ask questions. Who wrote this song? Is there a real testimony behind it? Does this music come from someone walking with Jesus, or is it just algorithmically generated content?
Worship is not ultimately about charts or creativity or innovation. It's about hearts lifted toward heaven—something no algorithm can imitate and no machine will ever understand.
Let me close with this thought. We live in an age where technology is advancing faster than our wisdom to use it well. The church needs to be thoughtful, biblical, and discerning. We can't just uncritically adopt every new tool because it's efficient or popular. We have to ask deeper questions about what we're shaping and what's shaping us.
Let me pray: Dearest Heavenly Father, You made us to worship You. Holy Spirit, You dwell is us and it is Your presence that causes our hearts to worship. Help us to follow Paul’s words and “sing with the spirit, and sing with understanding." Grant us discernment in the music we listen and in our daily engagement with You, Father. Give us wisdom every day in how we should engage with technology. We love you and so look forward to the day we will gather before Your throne to worship You forever. Teach us how Holy Spirit! In Your name, Lord Jesus, we pray, Amen.
Thank you for joining me today. This is a conversation we need to keep having as technology continues to advance. Let's be a church that uses tools wisely without letting tools replace what only humans can offer—genuine, Spirit-filled worship from hearts that have been transformed by grace.
Until next time, keep your eyes on the nations and remember—God is seeking worshipers, not worship products, and let us be a people who worship Him in Spirit and truth.
You can listen to this in podcast form at Spotify podcast
No comments:
Post a Comment